RAID 5 versus RAID 10, HDD and SSD
Let’s set some reference points upfront so that we can accurately discuss the differences between these two types of RAID arrays.
- RAID 5 is a RAID ((redundant array of independent disks) configuration that uses disk striping with parity. As data and parity are striped across all of the disks, no single disk creates a bottleneck.
- Conversely, RAID 10 combines disk mirroring and disk striping to protect data. RAID 10 requires a minimum of four disks, and stripes data across mirrored pairs. As long as one disk in each mirrored pair is functional, data can be retrieved. If two disks in the same mirrored pair fail, all data will be lost because there is no parity in the striped sets. RAID 10 provides redundancy and performance, and is the best option for I/O-intensive applications. One disadvantage is that only fifty percent of the total raw capacity of the drives is usable due to mirroring.
Raid 5 is less efficient on normal spinning hard disks (HDD) because it increases the number of random I/O operations. Writing small amounts of data more frequently results in slower performance than when writing larger amounts of data sequentially.
Conversely, SSDs can write random smaller blocks of data more efficiently. What’s more important though is knowing the total amount of data written to the drive.
A parity drive is a hard drive used in a RAID array to provide fault tolerance. For example, RAID 5 uses a parity drive to create a system that is both fault tolerant and, because of data striping, fast. One way to implement a parity drive in a RAID array is to use the exclusive or, or XOR, function.
Disk striping is the process of dividing a body of data into blocks and spreading the data blocks across multiple storage devices, such as hard disks or solid-state drives (SSDs). A stripe consists of the data divided across the set of hard disks or SSDs, and a striped unit, or strip, that refers to the data slice on an individual drive.
Writing hard amounts of data to the array at once
With RAID 5, you’re not writing the data five times over – it’s actually 1.25 times in total with ¼ to each of four drives and the additional to the fifth drive for parity. This helps improve data recovery.
With RAID 10, all of the data is mirrored, so when using four drives, ½ of the available write bandwidth is utilized to store copies of your data.
RAID 10 is more efficient in that it’s able to keep the drives active (at a maximum) more so than RAID 5. However, for maximum performance (actual writing speed), RAID 5 is better because less time is used storing information that is redundant.
If you’re testing efficiency between these two types of RAID configurations, be aware that your results will vary depending on the type of test data you’re utilizing. A single threaded test will produce different results than say, running multiple simultaneous write threads.
Brought to you by ProlimeHost
We’ve been in the web hosting industry for over a decade, helping hundreds of clients succeed in what they do best and that’s running their business. We specialize in Virtual Private Servers (VPS) and dedicated servers, with data centers in Los Angeles, Denver & Singapore.
VPS Services: Lightning Fast SSD Virtual Servers
Our Virtual Private Servers all feature high performance Xeon processors and SSD storage in a RAID10 configuration to optimize your server’s performance, which dramatically enhances visitor experiences on your site.
That speed is backed by unparalleled 24/7 support, featuring both outstanding response AND resolution times to maximize your uptime.
Now is the time to join the ProlimeHost virtual private server revolution.
Dedicated Servers: Backed by a 99.9% SLA network uptime guarantee
We only use enterprise-class hardware in our dedicated servers and offer a four (4) hour hardware replacement. Throw in IPMI for remote management, support for public and private networks, free operating system (OS) re-installs, and SATA, SAS & SSD (including NVMe) storage. Call +1 877 477 9454 or email us at Sales@ProlimeHost.com. We’re here to help.